Why did Google buy Motorola for $12.5 billion and sell it off for $2.91 billion?

samsung-galaxy-s-4-white-three-up-front-profile-back

Google’s move was a strategic masterpiece. It positioned itself as a major smart phone player without actually owning any hardware manufacturing business unit in the end. The deal had a twofold objective.

[1] acquiring a chunk of patents owned by Motorola.
[2] showing other Android major smart phone makers (read Samsung) who’s the boss.

Samsung is giant. It employs 427,000 staff, has an annual turnover in excess of $270bn and assets of $600bn spread across over 80 business units.

And Google just floored it twice using Motorola as a baseball bat.On the surface having 81 per cent of Android marketshare would seem to make Google and Samsung best buddies. Samsung has been the driving force behind Android’s meteoric growth and put Google mobile devices in pole position.

The problem is Samsung wanted too much credit. It wasn’t enough for Samsung to make the most popular Android phones and tablets, it had to hide Android – and consequently Google’s role in its achievement. It did this using ‘TouchWiz’, the company’s proprietary skin which painted over all aspects of Android leaving it unrecognisable. To the casual consumer they were buying ‘a Samsung’, Google’s role was largely unrecognised.Samsung then exploited this further. It put TouchWiz on its smart TVs, another market it dominates, and began building its own Android rival – Tizen – which, thanks to its TouchWiz interface, looks identical to the casual observer. The long term strategy was clear: switch over to Tizen and take the majority of the handset market with it. Google had to act.

How?

The ‘how’ was Motorola. On 15 August 2011 Google announced it had bought Motorola Mobility for $12.5bn in cash. With it Google acquired more than 20,000 mobile patents and publicly declared the purchase of the phone maker would not in any way compromise relationships with its handset partners… honestly, really, pinky swear.

Of course Google didn’t expect handset partners to fully believe this and platitudes issued from them in reaction to the deal confirmed it. Should Google use Motorola to ramp up its own major handset business the market would be theirs. The phones would have stock Android and no-one, not even Samsung, could afford to subsidise their cost as Google can leveraging its mammoth advertising revenue.

The bait was set: obliteration by Google stock Android handsets unless manufacturers (read: Samsung) stopped messing with Android. Google quietly showed it could walk the walk as well as it ramped up Nexus production and introduced the well-received Motorola Moto X and Motorola Moto G which stripped away almost all customisation from stock Android.

Samsung bit. On 27 January 2014 Google and Samsung signed a wide-ranging global patent deal which will last a decade. Buried within it was an agreement that Samsung would tone down TouchWiz, refocus on core Android apps over its own customisations and cancel more radical customisations such as its ‘Magazine UX’ interface. Two days later Google announced the sale of Motorola Mobility to Lenovo showing both agreements had been working in parallel.

The consequences

The smack down for Samsung is twofold.

Firstly, despite its size and dominance of the Android market, Samsung has been brought back into line. No longer will Samsung run roughshod over Android’s design, kick out its apps in favour of Samsung alternatives and hide Google’s hard work underneath. Indications of a low key Galaxy S5 launch suggest it will stand by its word.

Secondly, the jump off point for Samsung from Android to Tizen is no longer straightforward. With Android shining through more strongly in future Samsung handsets it won’t be a seamless switch from one to the other. If Samsung wants Tizen to succeed it will now have to be earned rather than snuck in under the radar.

Edit 1: Simplifying and updating the transaction details (19th April, 2015)

And did Google really take a $10bn loss as reported? It’s a disproportionate figure calculated by subtracting Motorola’s $2.91bn sale price from its $12.5bn purchase price. Let’s look at the actual transactions.

After purchasing Motorola for $12.5bn, it obtained the Motorola Home and Motorola Mobility divisions. Google immediately sold the Motorola Home division to Arris Group Inc for about $2.5bn. Google sold the Motorola Mobility division to Lenovo for about $3bn. Motorola had $3bn in cash at the time Google purchased it. Also there were other tax assets (reportedly up to about $2.5bn) as well. A quick calculation and you can tell that Google paid about $2.5bn-$3bn and retained $3.5bn worth of Motorola patents and the company’s cutting edge research lab.

Well played Google. Well played.

 

Ref :

[1] Answer of ,

Dhruv Sangvikar

Dhruv Sangvikar 

@

https://www.quora.com/Why-did-Google-buy-Motorola-for-12-5-billion-and-sell-it-off-for-2-91-billion

[2] http://www.forbes.com/sites/gordonkelly/2014/02/10/how-google-used-motorola-to-smack-down-samsung-twice/#6099c9fb53ab

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s